Broke Straight Boys
Broke Straight Boys 2876 Broke Straight Boys Broke Straight Boys began in 2006 and has kept to its promised niche ever since.
Trial price $ 1.00
Discount price $ 19.95
Monthly price $ 29.95
Our total rating: 84/10001

Broke Straight Boys

Reviewed 2020-09-27 l Last update on

Short Review

Broke Straight Boys began in 2006 and has kept to its promised niche ever since. It now has over 2,000 movies featuring genuine straight, gay and bi amateurs, often in their first-time suck and fuck scenes, it's up to 1080p HD now, and shows no signs of slowing down with its weekly updates. Videos, photos and a model index are included along with three bonus sites from the same team, and right now, there's reduced price entry to what is still the original and best gay-for-pay porn.

  • Trial: $1.00
  • Monthly: $19.95
84/100 0
Discount Price Save 33%
get discount


  • Exclusivity: 5/5
  • Updates: 4/5
  • Originality: 8/10
  • Quality: 12/15
  • Speed: 12/15
  • Quantity: 14/15

The idea behind Broke Straight Boys is simple. Amateur guys, aged from 18 to around 30, sign up to the idea of making a gay porn flick. They are interviewed, they team up with another similar straight guy or go solo, and if they do exactly as they're asked, they get paid afterwards. There's a hot mix of guys with army boys, students and others who will do anything for cash, and there's a mix of bareback, BJs and mutual masturbation in raw and natural scenes. They guys are interviewed before and sometimes after their shoots, so you get to find out what they as str8 boys think about sucking cock for the first time, or getting their virgin cherries popped by another man.

All that makes for horny stuff, but what has always made this site work is the naturalness of the proceedings. The interviews at the start let you get to know the guys, and among the 396 BTS scenes also included, you have plenty of conversations to watch where you see how nervous the boys were, or how bullish about what was expected, and then you can flip over and see the scenes for yourself. Some of the scenes are parts, with before, during and after, others are the full thing, but each one runs for around 20 + minutes, and features at least one ordinary, natural guy.

There are 522 models to choose from, mainly with stats and a couple of snippets of info, but always with a good face or body sot to whet your appetite. You find a nice mix of Latino, black and white boys, a few Asians, redheads, blond boys and dark, smooth and hairy, cut and uncut, and most are reasonably fit, but all have a great amateur vibe to them. Since the site started, they've kept to their brief of finding ordinary guys who simply want some cash, but unlike some fake 'first-time' sites, you really do get the impression that some of these lads were at first reluctant to touch another guy's dick, let alone suck it or get fucked by it. Some of my favourite scenes involved a straight boy and a more experienced gay guy who guides them through losing their gay virginity, but all scenes are hot to watch whether they are solos or duos.

You've got 1,926 main movies now, and Broke Straight Boys continues to update regularly once a week and has done since we reviewed it back in the early days. The format's the same, with chat, strip, temptation and full-on fuck scene, but the resolutions of playback have changed and improved over the years. Older scenes are Mp4 and WMV and average quality at 480 x 360, with streaming and downloading options, but visual quality is fine. Newer scenes come with up to five options for streaming and downloading in Mp4 right up to 1,920 x 1,080 HD, and look perfect. The sound is also good and clear, and the camerawork is kind of hand-held but not trashy, with edits to cum shots and plenty of close and distant angles, so everyone is kept happy.

Movies come with images, and there are usually around 40 pics each at 600 x 900 px that you can browse through and save or take in a zipped file. Again, quality is fine, and there are plenty of hardcore shots to save. Movies also come with descriptions.

Along with the 1,926 videos and 396 behind the scenes clips and outtakes, you've got access to three bonus sites from the same team. HS Boys (a feed site collection), College Boy Physicals (630 + scenes) and Straight Boys Jerk Off (260 scenes) are included, and you'll find the links at the top of the pages.

Nav, Design & Features

  • Design: 4/5
  • Navigation Ease: 8/10
  • Features: 8/10

Broke Straight Boys has always had a simple look to it, and that look seems the same now as when we last reviewed it. The tour has changed and is presented in a much more modern way than the members' area, but everything still works fine, and you've got various ways to find the guys you want to see. The model index gives face pics and links and is a handy tool, there's a page of tags with category headings to use as a site-wide filter, and a basic search function. You can rearrange the content and save movies to a favourites area for later.

Viewing pages let you rate and comment on content, the descriptions are well written, and the main menu is easy to follow. So, you're not going to have any navigational issues, just be aware that the bonus sites open in the same window, and you'll need your membership details to access them.

Currently, memberships are priced at $19.95 for the month, recurring, and at $49.85 if you only want to take one month, non-recurring. There is a trial offer, but it comes back at a higher price and limits you to streaming only, and the $19.95 monthly option is reduced from the usual price of $24.95, so that seems to be the best way to go.

Members Area Screenshots


We last saw Straight Broke Boys some years ago, and a few things have changed, mainly the quality of the movies, now being HD, and the number of them. Updates have been regular, the quality of amateur guys remains just as good and varied, the movies are the same theme, and all the site has done is grow in size and lowered its membership price. So, everyone's a winner, especially if you like to see real straight and bi boys suck and fuck for the first time.

Pros & Cons

  • + Exclusive
  • + Regular updates
  • + High content count
  • + Genuine amateurs
  • + Easy to use
  • + Three bonus sites
  • - Cross sale on sign up
  • - Limited trial
  • - Older movies not HD